How to make a thick, smooth ice cream milkshake at home: You can still make one without a blender

Update: The content was reviewed against the reference sources listed at the end of the article at the time of editing. Information that may vary depending on the product, equipment or food safety guidance should be checked again before use.

What does a thick, smooth milkshake depend on?

Making a milkshake at home is suitable for those who want to mix their own cold drink, try new flavours or prepare ideas for a drinks menu. A thick, smooth texture depends largely on the ratio of ice cream to milk and how the ice cream is handled before mixing.

According to the Food Network guide, an easy ratio to start with is 1 cup ice cream to 1/4 cup milk. This starting ratio helps home makers control the thickness before adding other ingredients.

The ice cream should be removed from the freezer 10–15 minutes beforehand. You can also chill the glass in the freezer for the same length of time to keep the drink cold when poured into the glass. When making a milkshake, it is best to start with the correct amount of milk rather than adding a lot of milk at the beginning.

For a thick, smooth ice cream milkshake, control the ice cream and milk base first, then adjust the flavour with mix-ins or toppings.

Ingredients and equipment to prepare

Ingredients

• 1 cup ice cream.
• 1/4 cup milk.
• Optional mix-ins such as syrup, fruit, nut butter or biscuits.
• Optional toppings such as whipped cream, biscuit crumbs, sprinkles, drizzled syrup or grated chocolate.

The mix-ins and toppings above are options suggested in the reference source. The source does not specify quantities for each type, so consider them customisable additions based on taste, rather than mandatory ingredients in the recipe.

Equipment

• Blender or hand blender, if available.
• Large bowl or wide-mouthed measuring jug when using a hand blender.
• A jar with a tight-fitting lid, spoon and whisk if mixing by hand.
• Serving glass.

How to make a milkshake using a blender

1. Remove the ice cream from the freezer 10–15 minutes beforehand to soften it. If you want the drink to stay cold for longer when served, place the glass in the freezer for the same length of time.
2. Measure 1 cup ice cream and 1/4 cup milk. Measuring them separately gives you better control over the texture than estimating by eye.
3. Put the milk and ice cream into the blender, then blend until smooth.
4. Add mix-ins if desired and continue blending until suitably combined. Crunchy ingredients such as biscuits or chocolate pieces can be added at the end to retain some chewiness.
5. Pour the milkshake into the chilled glass, add toppings and serve immediately.

The key tip when learning how to make a milkshake: start with a ratio of 1 cup ice cream to 1/4 cup milk. If you increase the milk at the beginning without adjusting the ratio, the milkshake may not reach the desired thickness; mix-ins should be added after the ice cream and milk have combined.

How to make a milkshake without a blender

Method 1: Using a hand blender

Place the softened ice cream and milk in a large bowl or wide-mouthed measuring jug, then use a hand blender to mix until smooth. This is a way to make a milkshake without a jug blender that is directly mentioned in the reference source.

Method 2: Using a spoon or whisk

Place the softened ice cream and milk in a bowl, then mix by hand with a spoon or whisk until combined. This method requires more thorough mixing, so keep to the initial ratio and avoid adding more milk before checking the texture.

Method 3: Using a lidded jar

Place the softened ice cream and milk in a lidded jar, use a spoon to press the ice cream down, then seal the jar and shake vigorously to mix. Leave enough space for the mixture to move around in the jar, and check that the lid is securely closed before shaking.

Whichever method you use, softening the ice cream remains important. The reference source does not provide a fixed shaking or mixing time for each piece of equipment, so it should not be treated as a mandatory figure.

Mix-in and topping suggestions

Once the basic milkshake is smooth, you can create many versions using syrup, fruit, nut butter, biscuits, chocolate pieces, cinnamon, mint, coffee or cocoa powder. For crunchy ingredients, add them at the end of the mixing process if you want to retain the contrast in texture.

Toppings may include whipped cream, sprinkles, cherry, biscuit sticks, drizzled syrup, sprinkled spices, grated chocolate or biscuit crumbs. If you would like to explore more ways to choose an ice cream base for homemade drinks or develop a menu, you can view Gelato Pro Ice Cream and Baby Boss Gelato Products.

Common mistakes when making a milkshake

Problem	Possible cause	Recommended solution
Milkshake is too thin	More milk was added than the starting ratio.	Start with a ratio of 1 cup ice cream to 1/4 cup milk; only add other ingredients after the base has combined.
Difficult to mix with manual equipment	The ice cream is still too hard.	Remove the ice cream 10–15 minutes beforehand to soften it.
The drink quickly loses its chill when poured	The glass was not chilled beforehand.	Place the glass in the freezer while waiting for the ice cream to soften.
Crunchy mix-ins become too finely crushed	They were added and blended for too long.	Add crunchy ingredients at the end of the mixing process.

The table above distinguishes between technical tips included in the source and practical inferences from the mixing method. This is an operating guide for making milkshakes at home, not a mandatory standard for every type of ice cream, milk or equipment.

Storage and when to enjoy

The accepted source advises pouring the milkshake into a glass and serving it immediately after mixing. The source does not provide a storage time, shelf life or guidance for maintaining the texture in the fridge, so Baby Boss does not give a storage figure for this recipe.

If making it at home, prepare an amount suitable for immediate use and prioritise enjoying it as soon as it is finished. Safe food handling principles should be applied according to guidance appropriate for the type of ingredients you use. You can also refer to the WHO Five Keys to Safer Food; this article does not replace professional food safety guidance.

Summary of how to make a milkshake

• Soften the ice cream for 10–15 minutes beforehand and chill the glass if you want to serve it colder.
• Start with a ratio of 1 cup ice cream to 1/4 cup milk.
• You can use a blender, hand blender, spoon, whisk or lidded jar.
• Add mix-ins after the ice cream and milk base have combined; add crunchy ingredients at the end if you want to retain their texture.
• Serve immediately after mixing because the source does not confirm a storage time.

If you are building a drinks menu for an F&B business model or want to develop an ice cream sales model, also see Baby Boss's Mixing Guide and Gelato Ice Cream Setup Consultation.

Partner with Baby Boss

Explore our products and Baby Boss services, or call 1900998880.

Shopee · TikTok · Instagram · Threads · YouTube · LinkedIn · Zalo OA · Pinterest