Why Choose OEM/ODM Ice Cream Instead of Making It Yourself? A Decision Framework for F&B Owners

An ice cream product may take up only a few lines on the menu, but behind it there may be an entire system involving recipes, people, equipment, cold storage and batch-by-batch controls. Therefore, the question of why a business should choose OEM/ODM ice cream instead of making it in-house cannot be answered with a single price list.

Contract manufacturing is worth considering when a shop wants to devote its resources to sales, service and developing its outlets rather than building the entire production capability itself. However, it is not automatically the less costly or less risky option. Its effectiveness depends on the scope of work, ownership rights over the recipe, order volume, storage capacity and responsibility when the finished product does not meet the agreed requirements.

Do not decide based solely on the two labels OEM and ODM

The potential for confusion lies in the terminology itself. One guide by CosKorea Group describes OEM as choosing an existing recipe, while ODM means developing a recipe to order. Meanwhile, Luminara Biotech uses OEM for cases where the brand brings a recipe to the factory, and ODM for an arrangement in which the manufacturer is responsible for developing the recipe.

Dermavelle Wellness also uses ODM for choosing and adjusting an existing recipe, while OEM begins closer to a specific development brief. These three documents are from the cosmetics industry, not the food industry. Therefore, their figures for costs, timelines or production volumes should not be applied to ice cream.

Even so, the differences in terminology point to a useful principle: do not buy an abbreviation; agree the scope of work. The shop owner should require the manufacturer to explain it in terms of specific tasks:

• Who develops, adjusts and approves the recipe?
• Who owns the recipe and the development data?
• Which ingredients, flavours, textures or specifications may be changed?
• Who purchases the ingredients and takes responsibility for their sources?
• Who prepares the documentation for the product and each batch?
• What happens if the finished product does not meet the agreed criteria?

Only when these questions have clear answers will the shop owner have a basis for comparing OEM/ODM ice cream with the option of producing it in-house.

When is contract manufacturing more worth considering than making it in-house?

The shop does not want to turn itself into a manufacturing operation

Making ice cream in-house involves more than mixing ingredients. The shop needs someone responsible for the recipe, monitoring each batch, recording deviations and dealing with finished products that do not meet requirements. It must also consider how the work will be handed over if the person responsible leaves or changes roles.

If the current team needs to focus its efforts on drinks, the kitchen, service and counter sales, contract manufacturing may help separate production from shop operations. The extent of that separation must be clearly stated in the agreement; the terms OEM or ODM do not create that division of responsibilities automatically.

The launch date matters more than absolute exclusivity

The aforementioned documents from outside the food industry place budget, launch timing and the degree of differentiation on the same set of scales. This may provide a framework for questions for the shop owner, but decisions about ice cream must still be based on samples, quotations and documentation supplied by the food manufacturer itself.

If the shop needs to meet an opening date, change its menu or prepare for a sales season, starting with an existing base product may be worth considering. In return, the shop owner should ask directly: is that product base supplied to other businesses, how extensive are the possible adjustments and what conditions apply if the shop wants exclusivity?

The need is not yet clear enough to invest in a separate system

When it is not yet known which flavours are suitable, what the expected sales volume will be or what price customers will accept, investing in the full capability to produce in-house will create many difficult-to-reverse commitments. A contract-manufacturing project with a moderate scope allows the shop to assess the role of ice cream in its menu before investing further.

However, placing the first order does not mean the risk of excess stock disappears by itself. The shop must still compare the minimum order volume with storage capacity and sales rate. Figures for production volume, shelf life, transport and storage must be obtained from the partner together with the documentation applicable to each product.

The shop wants to expand but does not want quality to depend on one person

A recipe that exists only in the memory of the person who makes it is very difficult to transfer. When serving customers at multiple outlets, the shop needs consistent acceptance criteria, receiving specifications, storage conditions and usage instructions.

A contract-manufacturing partner offers this advantage only if it can demonstrate the ability to meet the agreed criteria. The shop owner should not infer capability from the OEM or ODM label; they should check the sample products, handover documents and provisions for dealing with deviations.

Three cases in which making it in-house may be more suitable

Contract manufacturing is not the default answer. In-house production is worth considering when the ability to make ice cream is genuinely part of the shop’s business advantage, rather than an activity added after introducing a new menu item.

• The recipe is central to the positioning: the shop wants deep control over ingredients, texture and the direction of flavour development, while not wanting to be limited by the partner’s scope for customisation.
• The team already has someone responsible: The development of the recipe, operations, batch records and finished-product checks has been specifically assigned, rather than simply added to the workload of staff who are already busy serving customers.
• The shop accepts the need for long-term investment: the decision is made after considering the equipment, space, staff, testing time and impact on the core business.

If these three conditions exist only in the plan, it is not yet possible to conclude that making products in-house will be cheaper. The cost table should include the time of the owner and team, not just ingredients and equipment. You can also refer to more content on organising operations in the F&B business guide.

Comparison table of the two options

Rather than trying to find an option that wins on every criterion, the owner should identify which factors carry the greatest weight for their business model.

A bakery adding a scoop of ice cream as an accompaniment faces a different set of considerations from a brand that sees Gelato as its core product. Therefore, each criterion should be weighted according to the actual objectives, rather than scored equally across the board.

Questions to ask the manufacturer before signing

A price only has meaning when the accompanying conditions are clear. For a fair comparison, the owner should send the same brief to each partner and ask them to respond in writing.

1. Is this an existing recipe, an adjusted recipe or a separately developed recipe?
2. Who owns the recipe and development data after the project ends?
3. Can the shop use this recipe with another manufacturer?
4. If applicable, is the scope of exclusivity defined by recipe, region or time period?
5. Which factors can be adjusted: flavour, texture, ingredients or packaging specifications?
6. Is the minimum production volume calculated by flavour, by specification or across the entire order?
7. How are the times for sampling, sample approval and production confirmed?
8. What does the finished-product acceptance criteria include?
9. Which documents does the partner hand over for each product and each batch?
10. How are responsibility for transport, receipt and storage divided?
11. If the finished product does not meet the agreed criteria, what is the handling process?
12. When the production volume increases, how do the price, production schedule and ordering conditions change?
13. Which items are not included in the quotation, such as sampling, development, packaging, transport or storage?

“Full-service” is not yet a scope of work. Each task should be linked to the responsible party, handover documents and acceptance conditions. The owner should also separate mandatory requirements from negotiable preferences to avoid prolonging the sampling process.

How to test the model without betting the entire menu

The trial scope should be narrow enough to control inventory but realistic enough to observe operations at the counter. Rather than putting many flavours on the menu at once, the shop can start with a product group serving one clear objective, such as desserts, products served with cake or a core ice cream range.

1. Write the brief: identify the target customers, the role of ice cream on the menu, the expected price point, storage conditions and serving method.
2. Set the criteria before testing samples: assess suitability for the accompanying dish, serving process and quality under the expected operating conditions.
3. Request quotations for the same scope: avoid comparing two prices for two different work packages.
4. Track incoming stock, sales and remaining stock: record using point-of-sale data rather than relying solely on impressions after a few days.
5. Only expand once the target has been met: increase flavour variety or output after reviewing sales performance, stock levels and service capacity.

If the gelato is combined with drinks or other desserts, the team can refer to the mixing guide to organise procedures at the counter. The recipe, quantities and storage conditions must still follow the documentation for the actual product.

How does Baby Boss take part in Gelato contract manufacturing projects?

This article was published on a Baby Boss channel. Baby Boss offers Gelato contract manufacturing; therefore, the appropriate role in a specific project is to discuss whether the shop needs a base product, a certain level of customisation or a bespoke development direction, rather than assigning an OEM or ODM label in advance.

Before making contact, the owner should prepare a one-page brief covering the shop format, the role of gelato in the menu, the number of sales locations, the expected timeline, storage capacity and any mandatory requirements. The clearer the brief, the easier it is for both parties to identify which points need to be confirmed through samples, a quotation or an agreement.

You can send your requirements via the Baby Boss contact page. Output, timelines, handover documents, the scope of customisation and the rights to use the recipe need to be confirmed separately for each project and should not be inferred from a general service package.

Ultimately, the useful question is not “Is OEM/ODM better than making it yourself?”. The decision to make is: which capabilities the shop should own directly, which elements can be outsourced and what conditions will allow the shop to remain in control of the product bearing its name.

Partner with Baby Boss

Explore products and Baby Boss services, or call 1900998880.

Shopee · TikTok · Instagram · Threads · YouTube · LinkedIn · Zalo OA · Pinterest